Initially, when I saw this assignment was due this week, I was a little overwhelmed because I though that wine and cheese pairings were extremely fancy and it was very difficult to find good cheese to pair with the wine. I was sorely mistaken. This assignment was very fun and it actually helped me gain a new appreciation for some wine, specifically the Zinfandel I tried. This leads me to the three wines I tried.
1. Bogle Family Vineyards Old Vine Zinfandel
2. Martin Codax Albarino
3. Dark Horse Pinot Noir
You've got the wines, now here are the cheeses that were tried with these wines
1. Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese
2. Great Value Colby Jack Cheese
3. Sargento Provolone
Now, lets get into each wine specifically:
1. Bogle Family Vineyards Zinfandel
- This wine by itself was fruity upfront, and then finished with a bitter, tannic taste in the mouth. It was very good, but like I said the tannins were strong on the finish. Some of the fruit notes I picked up on were blackberry and cherry.
Paired with the sharp cheddar:
- This pairing really surprised me. Like I just mentioned, the wine by itself left my mouth with a bitter taste, and the cheese by itself was also very aggressive and bitter. But when I took a bite of the cheese and then drank some wine while I was working on the cheese, they came together and almost created like a sweet flavor. It was like the bitterness of both of them cancelled each other out and it revealed more sweet, fruity flavors of the wine.
Paired with the provolone:
- Was not a big fan of this pairing at all really. It just seemed like these two just could not get in balance, as it both of the bad things were brought out. The sweet, fruity flavors that were present in the wine by itself were masked by the flavors of the provolone (which I am not a huge fan of to begin with), but then kept the bitter finish.
Paired with the colby jack:
- This pairing was not bad, but where the cheddar worked with the zinfandel and almost brought out sweet, fruity characteristics, this was the opposite. I feel like the two paired together and enhanced the bitterness of the colby jack while also bringing out the same fruity characteristics I tasted in the zinfandel when I paired it with the cheddar.
2. Martin Codax Albarino
- By itself, this wine was really good. It was fruity at first, and I made note of the pear and apple notes I got from this wine. While it was rather fruity at first, this wine finished dry.
Paired with the sharp cheddar cheese:
- I felt like the wine got completely overpowered by this cheese. I could not really get much of the fruity notes, honestly it was just the cheddar that I tasted. I think this wine was too light bodied to compete with the cheddar. I do not think this was a bad pairing, as I did not mind the taste when the two combined, I just feel like the sharpness of the cheddar was too much to bring anything out in the wine that the wine could not express on its own.
Paired with the provolone:
- This pairing with the provolone was way better than the Zinfandel with the provolone. Feel like these two actually were able to play off each other in a way, as the wine took a little bit of the bite off the provolone with the pear and apple flavors. I don't know however if anything necessarily gets brought out by these two pairing, but the two seem to play off each other nicely.
Paired with the colby jack:
- Honestly really good. I feel like the not-too-bitterness of the colby jack, combined with the flavor it does bring to the table does a good job of bringing out the apple notes in the wine. While I did taste the apple in the wine by itself, I had also tasted the pear and it seemed like the two were pretty even. That was not the case when paired with this cheese. The apple for some reason really jumped out.
2. Dark Horse Pinot Noir
- Tasting this wine by itself, one thing that really jumped out to me was the strawberry flavors. I was also able to get some cherry, but strawberry was definitely the first fruit to show itself. In addition to the fruit flavors I got, this wine was also very smooth on the finish, and did not seem to tannic.
Paired with the cheddar:
- This really surprised me, I did not go into this pairing expecting much from these two. The cheddar seemed to really bring out the strawberry/cherry flavors in the wine while maintaining the smooth finish I tasted in the wine initially. It also seemed like the bold flavors in the cheddar held stronger with this wine than the provolone or colby jack did.
Paired with the provolone:
- Honestly I did not like this pairing at all. These two seemed to be the absolute worst as the cheese seemingly took away the fruity characteristics all together. This could just be tied back to me not really liking provolone, but I definitely had higher expectations for this wine.
Paired with the colby jack:
- This was a great pairing, I felt, much like the cheddar, the fruit really got enhanced by this pairing, but the wine finishes kind of bitter when combined with the colby jack which I was a big fan of. I felt like the wine took the initial bite out of the cheese, but not so much to where one overpowers the other.
Overall, my favorite pairing was the Zinfandel with the cheddar cheese, which was probably a bad way to start this tasting with the best pairing, but oh well. My least favorite pairing was the Pinot Noir with the provolone. Something about the provolone just did not sit right with me for whatever reason.